The Film Room · Running Backs · Week 11

Week 11 RB Film Room: Earned Yards vs. Handed Carries

Carries Get Handed Out. Yards Get Earned. Trust the Earners.

Some backs gain more than anybody should with the ball they're given. Others get the ball and do nothing with it. Here's who to play in Week 11.

By Mohn Jadden  ·  Week 11 · Stats through Week 10

A carry is a decision. The yard after it is a result. Coaches make the first one, and runners make the second.

The league tracks how many more yards a back gains than a typical runner would. Same blocking, same defenders. We lined that up against how much of his team's rushing he gets. A few of these fellas are earning it for nobody. Others are being handed it and doing nothing with it.

Tap any dot
Derrick Henry (BAL): 0.08 rush yards over expected per carry, 66.1 share of team carries (%)Christian McCaffrey (SF): 0.31 rush yards over expected per carry, 43.7 share of team carries (%)Samaje Perine (CIN): 0.46 rush yards over expected per carry, 26.4 share of team carries (%)Tony Pollard (TEN): 0.61 rush yards over expected per carry, 68.9 share of team carries (%)David Montgomery (HOU): -0.43 rush yards over expected per carry, 44.4 share of team carries (%)Rico Dowdle (PIT): -0.07 rush yards over expected per carry, 33.6 share of team carries (%)J.K. Dobbins (DEN): -1.03 rush yards over expected per carry, 44.0 share of team carries (%)Jonathan Taylor (IND): 0.02 rush yards over expected per carry, 62.5 share of team carries (%)D'Andre Swift (CHI): -0.51 rush yards over expected per carry, 51.2 share of team carries (%)Chuba Hubbard (CAR): 0.75 rush yards over expected per carry, 72.9 share of team carries (%)Rhamondre Stevenson (NE): 0.14 rush yards over expected per carry, 38.9 share of team carries (%)Javonte Williams (DAL): 0.25 rush yards over expected per carry, 66.1 share of team carries (%)James Cook III (BUF): 0.91 rush yards over expected per carry, 63.8 share of team carries (%)Rachaad White (WAS): -0.06 rush yards over expected per carry, 29.4 share of team carries (%)Jordan Mason (MIN): -0.25 rush yards over expected per carry, 48.4 share of team carries (%)Brian Robinson Jr. (ATL): -0.07 rush yards over expected per carry, 29.9 share of team carries (%)Kyren Williams (LAR): 0.2 rush yards over expected per carry, 48.3 share of team carries (%)Kenneth Walker III (KC): 1.66 rush yards over expected per carry, 73.3 share of team carries (%)Bijan Robinson (ATL): 1.21 rush yards over expected per carry, 66.5 share of team carries (%)Kendre Miller (DAL): -1.11 rush yards over expected per carry, 39.6 share of team carries (%)Chase Brown (CIN): -0.2 rush yards over expected per carry, 57.4 share of team carries (%)Jahmyr Gibbs (DET): 0.69 rush yards over expected per carry, 75.4 share of team carries (%)Bucky Irving (TB): 0.7 rush yards over expected per carry, 56.8 share of team carries (%)Blake Corum (LAR): 0.49 rush yards over expected per carry, 35.8 share of team carries (%)Braelon Allen (NYJ): 0.95 rush yards over expected per carry, 50.4 share of team carries (%)MarShawn Lloyd (GB): -1.52 rush yards over expected per carry, 32.6 share of team carries (%)Ollie Gordon II (MIA): -0.01 rush yards over expected per carry, 57.0 share of team carries (%)Jacory Croskey-Merritt (WAS): -0.45 rush yards over expected per carry, 45.3 share of team carries (%)Woody Marks (HOU): -0.45 rush yards over expected per carry, 48.9 share of team carries (%)Omarion Hampton (LAC): -0.15 rush yards over expected per carry, 48.1 share of team carries (%)Cam Skattebo (NYG): 0.09 rush yards over expected per carry, 55.8 share of team carries (%)Bhayshul Tuten (JAX): -0.23 rush yards over expected per carry, 55.6 share of team carries (%)TreVeyon Henderson (NE): 0.0 rush yards over expected per carry, 30.1 share of team carries (%)Quinshon Judkins (CLE): -0.28 rush yards over expected per carry, 55.5 share of team carries (%)Mike Washington Jr. (LV): -0.14 rush yards over expected per carry, 32.1 share of team carries (%)Jeremiyah Love (ARI): -0.61 rush yards over expected per carry, 51.0 share of team carries (%)Kaelon Black (SF): -0.21 rush yards over expected per carry, 30.0 share of team carries (%)Jadarian Price (SEA): -0.7 rush yards over expected per carry, 33.5 share of team carries (%)Aaron Jones Sr. (MIN): -0.45 rush yards over expected per carry, 52.1 share of team carries (%)A. JONES SR.Saquon Barkley (PHI): 0.7 rush yards over expected per carry, 37.9 share of team carries (%)S. BARKLEYKenny Gainwell (TB): 1.22 rush yards over expected per carry, 21.4 share of team carries (%)K. GAINWELLJaylen Warren (PIT): 1.76 rush yards over expected per carry, 58.3 share of team carries (%)J. WARRENTyler Allgeier (ARI): 0.48 rush yards over expected per carry, 39.7 share of team carries (%)T. ALLGEIERBreece Hall (NYJ): -0.41 rush yards over expected per carry, 57.9 share of team carries (%)B. HALLAshton Jeanty (LV): -0.43 rush yards over expected per carry, 50.0 share of team carries (%)A. JEANTY
Every dot is a running back. Right means more rush yards over expected per carry. Up means a bigger share of his team's carries. The dashed lines are the middle of the pack.
See all 45 players as a table
#PlayerTeamRush yards over expected per carryShare of team carries (%)
1Jaylen WarrenPIT1.7658.3
2Kenneth Walker IIIKC1.6673.3
3Kenny GainwellTB1.2221.4
4Bijan RobinsonATL1.2166.5
5Braelon AllenNYJ0.9550.4
6James Cook IIIBUF0.9163.8
7Chuba HubbardCAR0.7572.9
8Saquon BarkleyPHI0.737.9
9Bucky IrvingTB0.756.8
10Jahmyr GibbsDET0.6975.4
11Tony PollardTEN0.6168.9
12Blake CorumLAR0.4935.8
13Tyler AllgeierARI0.4839.7
14Samaje PerineCIN0.4626.4
15Christian McCaffreySF0.3143.7
16Javonte WilliamsDAL0.2566.1
17Kyren WilliamsLAR0.248.3
18Rhamondre StevensonNE0.1438.9
19Cam SkatteboNYG0.0955.8
20Derrick HenryBAL0.0866.1
21Jonathan TaylorIND0.0262.5
22TreVeyon HendersonNE0.030.1
23Ollie Gordon IIMIA-0.0157.0
24Rachaad WhiteWAS-0.0629.4
25Rico DowdlePIT-0.0733.6
26Brian Robinson Jr.ATL-0.0729.9
27Mike Washington Jr.LV-0.1432.1
28Omarion HamptonLAC-0.1548.1
29Chase BrownCIN-0.257.4
30Kaelon BlackSF-0.2130.0
31Bhayshul TutenJAX-0.2355.6
32Jordan MasonMIN-0.2548.4
33Quinshon JudkinsCLE-0.2855.5
34Breece HallNYJ-0.4157.9
35David MontgomeryHOU-0.4344.4
36Ashton JeantyLV-0.4350.0
37Aaron Jones Sr.MIN-0.4552.1
38Jacory Croskey-MerrittWAS-0.4545.3
39Woody MarksHOU-0.4548.9
40D'Andre SwiftCHI-0.5151.2
41Jeremiyah LoveARI-0.6151.0
42Jadarian PriceSEA-0.733.5
43J.K. DobbinsDEN-1.0344.0
44Kendre MillerDAL-1.1139.6
45MarShawn LloydGB-1.5232.6

Top right is where you want to live. Earning it and getting handed it. Bottom right is the guy who earns it and doesn't get the ball. Top left is the opposite, and that's where the trouble hides.

Start Jaylen Warren, because nobody gains more with the ball

RB14
Jaylen WarrenPIT at PHI · Sun
14.8projected
floor 9.3Sources: ESPN 13.3 to FanDuel 15.9ceiling 19.1
Season
16.7 a gameRB10 of 96
Last 3
15.7 a game
Matchup
PHI is #25 of 32tough for RBs (1 = softest)
Rostered
96%started in 89%
Every game this season. Last three in white.
  • Tough matchup
  • Usage down
  • Steady
  • 1.76 rush yds over expected per carry · #1 of 51
  • 58.3% of team carries
  • 214.2 total rush yds over expected

Now here's a guy. Jaylen Warren.

Out of 51 backs, nobody gains more than a typical runner would in the same spot. He's first. That's the number I trust.

The worry is the carries. Last game he got seven and ran for 15 yards. Over the last three, he's down to 47 percent of Pittsburgh's rushes from 58 percent for the year. Five catches on six targets kept that day alive.

Here's why I don't panic. In Week 3 and Week 4 he got 17 carries each and turned them into 20.6 and 15.6. Give this fella the ball and something happens. Coaches notice that.

Philadelphia is rough on backs, 25th of 32. Pittsburgh is favored by 4.5, though, with 21.5 points expected. A team with a lead hands it off.

Look at the floor. His worst game all year was 9.1. The leagues starting him have it right.

StartPlay him with confidence, and worry only if Pittsburgh keeps shaving his carries.

Add Kenny Gainwell now and bench him this week

RB32
Kenny GainwellTB at DET · Sun
7.2projected
floor 3.3Sources: Sleeper 6.2 to CBS 8.6ceiling 10.2
Season
7.1 a gameRB42 of 96
Last 3
11.1 a game ▲
Matchup
DET is #31 of 32tough for RBs (1 = softest)
Rostered
44%started in 9%
Every game this season. Last three in white.
  • Tough matchup
  • Heating up
  • Usage up
  • Low team total
  • Big underdog
  • Boom or bust
  • 1.22 rush yds over expected per carry · #3 of 51
  • 21.4% of team carries
  • 76.7 total rush yds over expected

Fewer than one in ten leagues are starting Kenny Gainwell. More than four in ten have him rostered anyway.

Third of 51 in earning his yards. Only about a fifth of Tampa's carries, though. You can't gain yards on carries you don't get.

That's changing. His last three games put him at 30 percent of the carries, and the scores went 8.8, 14.0 and 10.6. In Week 8 he ran 25 times for 140 yards. A coach doesn't hand a guy 25 for fun. Week 7 was 14 carries for 88 yards. Then Week 9 went back to five carries, so the role isn't locked yet.

Now the bad news. Detroit is 31st of 32 against running backs, as tough as it gets. Tampa is a seven-point underdog and only expected to score 18.2. The blend has him at 7.23 and RB32.

So don't play him Sunday. Stash him and let the carries keep creeping.

AddPick him up now, and start him once the matchup softens and the share holds.

Sit Ashton Jeanty, whose floor is all catches

RB22
Ashton JeantyLV at DEN · Sun
11.9projected
floor 7.2Sources: ESPN 11.3 to FleaFlicker 12.5ceiling 15.6
Season
15.0 a gameRB16 of 96
Last 3
9.2 a game ▼
Matchup
DEN is #11 of 32middle for RBs (1 = softest)
Rostered
97%started in 87%
Every game this season. Last three in white.
  • Slumping
  • Usage down
  • Low team total
  • Big underdog
  • Steady
  • -0.43 rush yds over expected per carry · #41 of 51
  • 50.0% of team carries
  • -52.4 total rush yds over expected

Ashton Jeanty has 46 catches. That's the only reason this isn't uglier.

On the ground, he gets less than the blocking hands him. He's 41st of 51. For a while it didn't matter, because Las Vegas kept feeding him. He's held half the team's carries for the season.

These days it's 28 percent. The scores slid with it. 10.3, 7.0, 10.4, against a 15.0 average. His 32.7 in Week 1 is propping up that average.

Look at the carries by week. 23, 21 and 19 to open the season. Two in Week 8. Nine last week. That's a back losing his job one handoff at a time.

Sunday is Denver, a middle matchup, 11th of 32. Las Vegas is a ten-point underdog. The team total is 15.2. Trailing teams throw, and that keeps the catches coming. It also means fewer handoffs for a runner who isn't winning them.

Almost nine in ten leagues start him anyway.

SitPlay him only if your bench is thin. The carries aren't coming back.

Sit Aaron Jones Sr., and take ESPN's side

RB26
Aaron Jones Sr.MIN at SF · Sun
8.9projected
floor 3.1Sources: ESPN 6.6 to FanDuel 11.3ceiling 13.3
Season
10.6 a gameRB30 of 96
Last 3
7.2 a game ▼
Matchup
SF is #23 of 32middle for RBs (1 = softest)
Rostered
80%started in 46%
Every game this season. Last three in white.
  • Slumping
  • Usage down
  • Under-started
  • -0.45 rush yds over expected per carry · #42 of 51
  • 52.1% of team carries
  • 126 carries

FanDuel says Aaron Jones Sr. is a back you can start. ESPN says he's a body for your bench. I'm with ESPN.

He's 42nd of 51 at earning his yards. The carries were covering for that. He's had 52 percent of Minnesota's rushes for the year. Lately, it's 35 percent.

The first five games were a different man. He had 25 carries for 113 yards against New Orleans and cracked 14 points three times. Since then he's had 11 carries or fewer every game.

The scores tell the story. 6.0, 3.1, 12.5. That last one came with a touchdown. Touchdowns come and go, and a guy who loses yards per carry can't count on one.

San Francisco is the matchup, 23rd of 32. Minnesota is a three-point underdog, but the share is the problem. He's got a floor of 3.08 and little else.

Fewer than half of leagues start him. Join the other half.

SitStart him only if your other options are worse than a projection of 8.88.

Start Breece Hall, and yes, this one cuts against me

RB19
Breece HallNYJ at LAC · Sun
12.5projected
floor 6.9Sources: ESPN 11.1 to FanDuel 14.4ceiling 16.9
Season
13.8 a gameRB19 of 96
Last 3
11.7 a game
Matchup
LAC is #12 of 32middle for RBs (1 = softest)
Rostered
94%started in 80%
Every game this season. Last three in white.
  • Steady
  • -0.41 rush yds over expected per carry · #39 of 51
  • 57.9% of team carries
  • -31.0 total rush yds over expected

This is the one that keeps the argument honest.

Breece Hall is 39th of 51 at earning yards. He loses yards against what the blocking gives him. By my own rule, I should be selling him. I can't.

He's handed the ball. About 59 percent of the Jets' carries lately, and it's been that way all year. In five games, his worst was 8.5. He's never been a dud, and he's startable in four of five.

The last three have gone 8.5, 11.7 and 14.8, so he's climbing. Los Angeles is a middle matchup, 12th of 32, and New York is a three-point underdog, and 19.2 is the team total.

Week 1 tells you who he is. 22 carries, 102 yards, a touchdown, 19.8 points. That's volume doing the work.

Volume is a floor. It isn't a ceiling. That's why the argument lives with Warren and not here. Eight of every ten leagues play him. Correct.

StartPlay him for the floor, and cut him loose only if his carries fall under half.

Two more, real quick

  • Saquon Barkley, Philadelphia. He's 10th of 51 at earning yards with only 38 percent of the carries. The last three went 15.1, 12.4 and 8.2, and he plays just 37 percent of the snaps. Philadelphia is a 4.5-point underdog at home, with a team total of 17.0. Hold.
  • Tyler Allgeier, Arizona. He's 15th of 51 and carries 60 percent of the load over the last three. Then look at the scores. 36.1, then 6.6, then 1.4. At Kansas City, Arizona is a 15.5-point underdog expected to score 12.5. Sit.

Week 11 RB rankings, top 36

These are the blended projections for this week, in PPR scoring. The range is each player's floor to ceiling.

RankPlayerTeamOppProjRangeStatus
RB1Jahmyr GibbsDETTB23.915.3 to 30.9
RB2Kenneth Walker IIIKCARI20.612.0 to 27.6Questionable
RB3Christian McCaffreySFMIN19.412.5 to 24.9
RB4James Cook IIIBUFMIA18.912.2 to 24.4
RB5Javonte WilliamsDALTEN18.311.8 to 23.5
RB6Chuba HubbardCARBAL16.87.0 to 24.8
RB7Bucky IrvingTBDET16.69.8 to 22.1
RB8D'Andre SwiftCHINO16.48.7 to 22.6
RB9Tony PollardTENDAL16.36.5 to 24.2
RB10Derrick HenryBALCAR16.29.7 to 21.4
RB11Bhayshul TutenJAXNYG16.29.2 to 21.8
RB12Jonathan TaylorINDHOU15.56.8 to 22.5
RB13Chase BrownCINWAS15.37.7 to 21.4
RB14Jaylen WarrenPITPHI14.89.3 to 19.1
RB15Jonah ColemanDENLV14.44.8 to 22.0
RB16Cam SkatteboNYGJAX14.16.6 to 20.1
RB17Omarion HamptonLACNYJ13.05.5 to 18.9
RB18David MontgomeryHOUIND12.84.7 to 19.2
RB19Breece HallNYJLAC12.56.9 to 16.9
RB20Ollie Gordon IIMIABUF12.03.5 to 18.7
RB21Saquon BarkleyPHIPIT11.94.9 to 17.4
RB22Ashton JeantyLVDEN11.97.2 to 15.6
RB23Emmett JohnsonKCARI11.53.2 to 18.0
RB24Tyler AllgeierARIKC9.42.2 to 14.9
RB25Rachaad WhiteWASCIN9.12.7 to 14.1
RB26Aaron Jones Sr.MINSF8.93.1 to 13.3
RB27Travis Etienne Jr.NOCHI8.74.1 to 12.2
RB28Kyle MonangaiCHINO8.42.9 to 12.5Questionable
RB29Jordan MasonMINSF8.33.0 to 12.4
RB30J.K. DobbinsDENLV7.41.7 to 11.7
RB31Tyjae SpearsTENDAL7.43.0 to 10.7
RB32Kenny GainwellTBDET7.23.3 to 10.2
RB33Braelon AllenNYJLAC7.22.0 to 11.2
RB34Justice HillBALCAR7.23.7 to 9.9
RB35Rico DowdlePITPHI6.80.9 to 11.3
RB36Alvin KamaraNOCHI6.73.3 to 9.2

See full rankings

Week 11 RB Film Room FAQ

Should I start Breece Hall in Week 11?

Yes. Breece Hall projects 12.49 points as RB19 against the Chargers and has been startable in 80 percent of his games. He's handed about 59 percent of the Jets' carries, so the floor holds even though he doesn't earn extra yards.

Should I start Jaylen Warren in Week 11?

Yes. Jaylen Warren projects 14.8 points as RB14 and has never scored under 9.1 this season. He's first of 51 backs at rush yards over expected per carry, at 1.76.

Should I start Aaron Jones Sr. in Week 11?

No. Aaron Jones Sr. projects 8.88 points as RB26. He has 35 percent of Minnesota's carries over the last three, down from 52 percent for the season. Sit him unless you're out of options.

How to read this. Rush yards over expected per carry is how many more or fewer yards a back gains than a typical back would. That accounts for the blocking and the defenders. It comes from NFL Next Gen Stats, through Week 10. Share of team carries is the slice of his team's rushes that go to one player. Matchup rank runs from 1, the softest defense against running backs, to 32, the toughest. Roster and start rates come from Sleeper leagues. Weekly ranks blend projections from CBS, ESPN, FanDuel, FleaFlicker and Sleeper.

SEE EVERY WEEK 11 RANKING. FREE.