Week 11 Start 'Em, Sit 'Em: Five Starts and Five Sits
Cam Skattebo Just Scored 27.2. Sit Him Anyway.
Five starts and five sits on names you're stuck on. Stefon Diggs gets his own warning, because Washington plays Monday night.

By Mohn Jadden · Week 11 · Stats through Week 10
Cam Skattebo scored twice last Sunday and put up 27.2 points, and you want a repeat. I wouldn't count on one.
That's one of ten calls below. Five starts, five sits, and a few quick words on names you keep asking about. Wednesday's rankings covered some others, and they get a short list near the end.

See all 20 players the sources split on
| Player | Team | Rank | Low | Blend | High | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kenneth Walker III | KC | RB15 | FanDuel 3.0 | 15.0 | ESPN 22.1 | 19.1 |
| Emmett Johnson | KC | RB14 | ESPN 7.0 | 15.2 | CBS 22.1 | 15.1 |
| Brock Bowers | LV | TE6 | FanDuel 1.0 | 11.3 | Sleeper 14.8 | 13.8 |
| Chuba Hubbard | CAR | RB10 | FanDuel 11.2 | 16.5 | ESPN 19.9 | 8.7 |
| George Kittle | SF | TE3 | ESPN 11.1 | 13.3 | FanDuel 18.8 | 7.7 |
| Mike Evans | SF | WR41 | CBS 5.8 | 8.0 | Sleeper 13.2 | 7.3 |
| Jalen Coker | CAR | WR21 | ESPN 7.2 | 11.2 | FanDuel 14.4 | 7.2 |
| Josh Downs | KC | WR28 | ESPN 6.8 | 9.5 | CBS 13.6 | 6.8 |
| Jonathan Taylor | IND | RB13 | CBS 12.5 | 15.3 | ESPN 19.1 | 6.6 |
| Jordan Mason | MIN | RB26 | ESPN 6.4 | 8.8 | FanDuel 12.8 | 6.4 |
| Amon-Ra St. Brown | DET | WR4 | ESPN 15.4 | 19.0 | FleaFlicker 21.4 | 6.0 |
| C.J. Stroud | HOU | QB5 | FanDuel 18.3 | 20.7 | ESPN 24.2 | 5.9 |
| Ladd McConkey | LAC | WR32 | CBS 6.0 | 9.2 | Sleeper 11.9 | 5.9 |
| Jared Goff | DET | QB13 | ESPN 12.1 | 15.8 | FleaFlicker 17.7 | 5.6 |
| Cam Ward | TEN | QB12 | ESPN 13.5 | 16.4 | FleaFlicker 18.9 | 5.4 |
| Brock Purdy | SF | QB11 | ESPN 14.3 | 17.1 | FleaFlicker 19.7 | 5.3 |
| T.J. Hockenson | MIN | TE11 | CBS 6.2 | 9.1 | FanDuel 11.5 | 5.3 |
| Aaron Rodgers | PIT | QB17 | CBS 11.3 | 14.5 | Sleeper 16.5 | 5.1 |
| Colston Loveland | CHI | TE4 | ESPN 10.5 | 12.0 | FanDuel 15.1 | 4.6 |
| Dalton Kincaid | BUF | TE10 | ESPN 7.1 | 9.6 | CBS 11.5 | 4.4 |
Follow the white tick. The bar stretches left toward a bad day and right toward a great one. Matchup ranks run 1 to 32, and 1 is the softest defense.
Start Trevor Lawrence, because fourteen throws were enough
- Season
- 19.3 a gameQB7 of 35
- Last 3
- 20.3 a game
- Matchup
- NYG is #8 of 32soft for QBs (1 = softest)
- Rostered
- 94%started in 77%
- Soft matchup
- High team total
- Big favorite
Fourteen throws. That was Trevor Lawrence's whole Week 8, and he still scored 19.4. Three touchdowns on 10 completions will do that.
The flip side is what worries you. A week later he scored 13.58. Throw 14 times and you can score like it, and volume is the only real question here.
So look at the volume. His 28.34 came on 41 throws and last week's 27.78 on 35. Jacksonville is a 6-point favorite at the Giants, which is a game that stays close enough to throw. A 16-point favorite is a different story.
The rest is solid. Next Gen has his accuracy ninth of 34 against expectation, and New York ranks eighth-softest for passers. More than a fifth of leagues still bench him.
Start Kyle Monangai, the back nobody's playing
- Season
- 14.8 a game4 games
- Last 3
- 13.0 a game
- Matchup
- NO is #1 of 32soft for RBs (1 = softest)
- Rostered
- 74%started in 25%
- Soft matchup
- High team total
- Big favorite
- Under-started
Now here's a guy. Kyle Monangai. Four games played and a league that hasn't noticed.
Look at his bad days. A 7.8 and a 3.1, both on 10 carries. Look at the good one. Thirty carries, 146 yards, two scores, 28.0. His points follow his carries, and carries follow the scoreboard.
This week the scoreboard is on his side. Nobody in football is softer against running backs than New Orleans, and Chicago is projected for 30 points at home. Big favorites hand off late, and he took about 39 percent of the carries over his last three.
The sources aren't sold. He's RB27, and ESPN has him at just 5.8. Next Gen puts him fifth of 45 backs in yards over expected per carry. Don't ask him to catch, though. Four percent of the targets means it's carries or nothing.
Three in four leagues roster him. One in four plays him.
Start Rome Odunze, who hasn't had a dud all year
- Season
- 9.9 a gameWR40 of 156
- Last 3
- 13.2 a game ▲
- Matchup
- NO is #25 of 32tough for WRs (1 = softest)
- Rostered
- 88%started in 51%
- Tough matchup
- Heating up
- High team total
- Big favorite
Not one dud. Rome Odunze's worst game this season is a 5.0. He's gotten better each of the last three weeks, ending on a 16.0.
So why is half the league sitting him? The matchup, probably. New Orleans ranks 25th of 32 for receivers, and that's a real knock. But it's the same Chicago game I'm sending you to for Kyle Monangai, and Odunze is barely off the field. Points have to land on somebody.
A receiver can't score on targets he doesn't get, and this one gets them. His slice of the passing game is up a notch, 18 percent from 17. He's been startable 44 percent of the time, so he's safe and not spectacular.
Don't expect a monster. Boring is fine. I love boring.
Start DK Metcalf, the least exciting start of the week
- Season
- 10.1 a gameWR37 of 156
- Last 3
- 8.1 a game
- Matchup
- PHI is #3 of 32soft for WRs (1 = softest)
- Rostered
- 88%started in 61%
- Soft matchup
Pittsburgh at Philadelphia is a game with 37.5 points in it. DK Metcalf has been a 7.6, a 1.4 and a 15.4 lately. I'd start him anyway.
Start with the volume. He takes about 24 percent of Pittsburgh's targets and he's on the field for 93 percent of the snaps. Even the 1.4 came on six targets. The ball finds him.
What it doesn't do is stick. He's caught 35 of 70 passes thrown his way, and Next Gen has him 61st of 76 in getting open. That's the case against him, and it's a fair one.
But Philadelphia is the third-softest matchup in football for receivers. A soft draw is where a catch rate that low can climb. The sources have him WR29 this week, a little above his season rank of 37.
Six in ten leagues start him, so you're in the majority.
Start Travis Kelce, and ignore the 31 percent
- Season
- 11.6 a gameTE6 of 85
- Last 3
- 11.3 a game
- Matchup
- ARI is #4 of 32soft for TEs (1 = softest)
- Rostered
- 94%started in 82%
- Soft matchup
- High team total
- Big favorite
Thirty-one percent of the snaps. That's the number scaring you, and last week Travis Kelce caught two passes for five points.
Now look at the eight games before it. He never dropped under 66 percent in any of them. One short night doesn't rewrite a role, and he's had a dud just 11 percent of the time.
The game gives him a reason too. Arizona is the fourth-softest defense for tight ends, and Kansas City is a 15.5-point favorite. Next Gen has him fourth of 35 tight ends in getting open, so the targets that do come are clean ones.
My worry is a blowout that ends his day early. His target share has dipped to 15 percent from 18. Eight in ten leagues play him anyway.
Sit Cam Skattebo, because two touchdowns made the 27.2
- Season
- 13.9 a gameRB18 of 96
- Last 3
- 17.8 a game ▲
- Matchup
- JAX is #28 of 32tough for RBs (1 = softest)
- Rostered
- 95%started in 81%
- Tough matchup
- Heating up
- Big underdog
- Steady
Two touchdowns. That's half of Cam Skattebo's rushing scores all season, and they came in one game. Now four of every five leagues want to start the 27.2.
Look underneath it. Eighteen carries for 78 yards is fine and not special. His carry share is steady at about 54 percent, so the role is real. But that same role gave him a 7.1 as recently as Week 5.
Now the matchup. Jacksonville ranks 28th of 32 against backs, the tough end of the board. The Giants are a 6-point underdog at home, projected for 20.2. A team that trails hands off less late. His target share is just eight percent, so there's little catching to make it up.
He hasn't had a dud all year, so call this a lean. It's a lean I'd follow.
Sit Ollie Gordon II, because carries don't beat the scoreboard
- Season
- 11.9 a gameRB22 of 96
- Last 3
- 9.9 a game
- Matchup
- BUF is #10 of 32middle for RBs (1 = softest)
- Rostered
- 89%started in 75%
- Usage up
- Low team total
- Big underdog
Ollie Gordon II gets the ball. His carry share jumped to 79 percent over the last three from 57 on the season. That's the whole backfield.
Volume didn't buy points, though. Nineteen carries and a 6.9. Sixteen carries and a 7.4. Last week's 15.5 needed four catches on five targets to get there. His target share for the year is only seven percent.
Now Miami is a 16.5-point underdog at Buffalo, projected for 14.5 points. A team that far behind abandons the run. The 20 carries he got last week won't show up the same way.
The sources split on him too. ESPN has him at 16.6 and Sleeper at 11.28. I'm closer to Sleeper.
Three in four leagues start him. They're counting carries. I'm counting the scoreboard.
Sit Travis Etienne Jr., because his snaps keep shrinking
- Season
- 8.8 a game4 games
- Last 3
- 7.5 a game
- Matchup
- CHI is #21 of 32middle for RBs (1 = softest)
- Rostered
- 82%started in 38%
- Low team total
- Big underdog
- Under-started
Travis Etienne Jr. has played four games, and his snaps have shrunk every time. Fifty-nine percent, then 54, then 38, then 33 last week.
Nobody's stolen the carries outright. His carry share is about 37 percent either way. But there's no touchdown in it. Zero scores on 38 carries and 142 yards. The catches kept him alive, and last week that was three on five targets for a 6.4.
Then there's the game. New Orleans is an 11.5-point underdog at Chicago, projected for 18.5. That's the other side of the game I'm sending you to for Kyle Monangai. One backfield eats and the other watches.
Four of five leagues roster him, and fewer than four in ten start him. Leave him where he is.
Sit Stefon Diggs, and remember he plays Monday night
- Season
- 13.8 a gameWR21 of 156
- Last 3
- 13.7 a game
- Matchup
- CIN is #23 of 32middle for WRs (1 = softest)
- Rostered
- 89%started in 71%
- Big underdog
Washington plays Monday night. Your Sunday players are done before Stefon Diggs kicks off. A bad night for him is a bad night with nothing left to fix it.
Now the argument. Sort his season by one thing. Every game he's scored in is 12.8 or better. The games without one never topped 8.5. He's found the end zone in five of eight, on six touchdowns and 36 catches. That's a good receiver paid in lottery tickets.
The counterargument is real. Washington is a 6.5-point underdog in a game with 53.5 points in it. His target share is steady at about 23 percent. That's volume. I'll grant it.
But Cincinnati ranks 23rd of 32 against receivers, a middling draw, and it's the touchdown that pays.
Sit Dallas Goedert, because steady isn't enough
- Season
- 10.6 a gameTE9 of 85
- Last 3
- 9.0 a game
- Matchup
- PIT is #16 of 32middle for TEs (1 = softest)
- Rostered
- 68%started in 32%
- Low team total
Dallas Goedert has been the same tight end three weeks running. Everything landed between 7.2 and 10.0. That's steady, and it isn't enough.
The only blowup was Week 1, a 23.7 with two touchdowns. Those are his only two scores all year. Fewer than a third of his games have been worth starting, and the 10.6 average leans on that one night.
The game doesn't rescue him. Philadelphia is a 4.5-point underdog at home, projected for just 16.5. Pittsburgh is a middle matchup for tight ends, 16th of 32.
People are adding him fast, and I understand the pull. He's TE12 this week, his target share is 17 percent, and his role isn't going anywhere. But the points have nowhere to come from. Three in ten leagues start him.
Three you're worried about
- Isaiah Likely, Giants. Jacksonville ranks 26th of 32 against tight ends, and the Giants are a 6-point underdog. That's two strikes. But he's TE2 this week, caught nine passes for 127 yards last Sunday, and still sees 23 percent of the targets. Hold.
- Javonte Williams, Dallas. Two clunkers in his last three, 6.7 and 7.7, with a 22.4 wedged between them. The carries haven't gone anywhere, about 62 percent against 66 for the season. Dallas is a home favorite in a game with 54.5 points on the board, and he's RB4. Hold.
- Chris Olave, New Orleans. Four targets and six points hurt, and a 12 percent target share was his lowest all year. Over three games he's still at 25 percent, with no dud all season. The matchup is rough, 24th of 32 against receivers. Hold.
Already called this week
These were covered in Wednesday's rankings, and the calls stand.
- Bo Nix: start. The case is in the QB rankings.
- Brock Purdy: sit, big game or not. The QB rankings explain why.
- Jared Goff: sit. Same QB rankings, same answer.
- Ashton Jeanty: sit. The RB rankings and the Film Room lay it out.
- Ryan Flournoy: start. Find him in the WR rankings.
- Deebo Samuel Sr.: sit. The WR rankings have the reasoning.
- Jalen Coker: sit. Also in the WR rankings.
Week 11 Start 'Em, Sit 'Em FAQ
Should I start Jordan Mason in Week 11?
No. Jordan Mason is RB26 this week and averages 6.6 across five games. Next Gen has him 32nd of 45 backs in yards over expected per carry.
Should I start Josh Downs in Week 11?
Lean yes as a flex if your other receivers are ranked outside the top 30. Josh Downs is WR28 this week, and Kansas City is a 15.5-point favorite.
Should I start Stefon Diggs in Week 11?
Sit him if you own a Sunday receiver ranked 16th or better. Stefon Diggs is WR17 and plays Monday night. He has scored 12.8 or more in every game with a touchdown and 8.5 or less in every game without one.
Should I start Travis Etienne Jr. in Week 11?
No. Travis Etienne Jr. is RB24 this week, and his snaps have fallen to 33 percent from 59. New Orleans is an 11.5-point underdog. Play him only if your other backs are ranked outside the top 30.
Should I start Dallas Goedert in Week 11?
No, sit Dallas Goedert if your other tight end is ranked 11th or better. He is TE12 this week, and Philadelphia is projected for just 16.5 points.
Should I start Isaiah Likely in Week 11?
Yes. Isaiah Likely is TE2 this week with a 17.2 season average, and he caught nine passes for 127 yards last Sunday. Jacksonville is a tough draw for tight ends, 26th of 32, so it's a hold, not a bench.
Should I start DK Metcalf in Week 11?
Yes. DK Metcalf is WR29 this week and takes about 24 percent of Pittsburgh's targets. Philadelphia is the third-softest matchup for receivers. Play him over any receiver ranked 30th or worse.
Who should I start in Week 11?
Start Trevor Lawrence, Kyle Monangai, Rome Odunze, DK Metcalf and Travis Kelce. Each has a soft matchup, a big scoring game around him or both.
How to read this. Matchup rank runs from 1, the softest defense against that position, to 32, the toughest. Share is the slice of a team's targets, or carries for backs, that goes to one player. Rostered and started rates come from Sleeper leagues. Stats run through Week 10. Projections blend CBS, ESPN, FanDuel, FleaFlicker and Sleeper.
SEE EVERY WEEK 11 RANKING. FREE.






